Palm oil is derived from the fruit of the oil palm tree (Elaeis guineensis), which thrives in tropical regions. It is favoured for its high yield and versatility, making it an essential ingredient in numerous industries.
Introduction
Palm oil is one of the world's most widely used vegetable oils, and it is found in many food and cosmetics products. However, its production has sparked significant environmental concerns. This blog aims to dissect the myths and realities surrounding palm oil and its sustainability, providing a balanced perspective on its environmental impact.
My preferred cooking medium for fish and chips is beef dripping, as I enjoy its aroma. My wife also favours beef dripping, finding it helps combat her indigestion and heartburn. I'm flexible with the type of oils or fats used in cooking. However, I must admit that the crispiest and tastiest battered fish I've ever had was cooked in palm oil, while the best chips were made using rapeseed oil. This demonstrates that great fish and chips largely depend on cooking methods and the quality of ingredients.
Vegetable oil is a broad term for any oil extracted from plants. These oils are commonly used in cooking, baking, and food processing. The term "vegetable oil" can encompass a wide variety of oils, including:
Soybean Oil: One of the most common types derived from soybeans.
Canola Oil (Rapeseed Oil): Derived from the seeds of the canola plant, a variety of rapeseed.
Sunflower Oil: Extracted from sunflower seeds.
Corn Oil: Made from the germ of corn kernels.
Palm Oil: Sourced from the fruit of the oil palm tree.
Olive Oil: Obtained from olives, widely used in Mediterranean cuisine.
Peanut Oil: Extracted from peanuts, often used in Asian cuisine.
Grapeseed Oil: Derived from the seeds of grapes, a by-product of winemaking.
Coconut Oil: Made from coconut meat, it is used in cooking and cosmetics.
Vegetable oils are typically used for their neutral flavour and high smoke point, making them versatile for various cooking methods such as frying, baking, and sautéing. They can also be blended to achieve desired properties for specific culinary applications.
So when you're told it is vegetable oil, it could be any one of these or a mixture of some of these.
Why Did Palm Oil Get Such A Bad Wrap?
Palm oil has received significant criticism and a bad reputation primarily due to environmental, social, and health concerns. Here are the main reasons:
Environmental Impact
Deforestation: Large areas of tropical rainforests, particularly in Indonesia and Malaysia, have been cleared to make way for palm oil plantations. This deforestation has led to the loss of critical habitats for endangered species like orangutans, tigers, and elephants.
Biodiversity Loss: The conversion of diverse ecosystems into monoculture palm oil plantations has resulted in significant biodiversity loss. The destruction of habitats has put numerous species at risk of extinction.
Greenhouse Gas Emissions: The deforestation and drainage of peatlands for palm oil cultivation release large amounts of greenhouse gases, contributing to climate change. Peatlands, in particular, store vast amounts of carbon, and their destruction results in substantial carbon emissions.
Social Issues
Land Rights and Displacement: Indigenous peoples and local communities have often been displaced from their lands without proper compensation or consultation to make way for palm oil plantations. This has led to conflicts and human rights violations.
Labour Conditions: Reports of poor working conditions, child labour, and exploitation on palm oil plantations have raised significant ethical concerns. Workers are often subjected to low wages, long hours, and unsafe working environments.
Health Concerns
High Saturated Fat Content: Palm oil contains more saturated fats than other vegetable oils. Excessive consumption of saturated fats is linked to an increased risk of heart disease and other health issues.
Efforts to Address Issues
Despite these challenges, there have been significant efforts to address the negative impacts associated with palm oil production:
Sustainable Palm Oil: Initiatives such as the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) have been established to promote sustainable palm oil production. RSPO certification requires adherence to environmental and social standards, aiming to reduce deforestation and improve labour conditions.
Corporate Responsibility: Many companies have committed to sourcing only certified sustainable palm oil and improving transparency in their supply chains. This shift in corporate responsibility is crucial for driving industry-wide change.
Consumer Awareness: Increased consumer awareness about the environmental and social impacts of palm oil has led to greater demand for sustainably sourced products. Educated consumers are now more likely to support brands that commit to ethical sourcing practices.
Big Brands Leading the Way to Sustainability
1. Dr. Bronner’s
Dr Bronner uses organic and fair-trade palm oil in its soap products. It works with farmers and suppliers who protect rainforests, improve soil quality, and safeguard animal habitats, ensuring fair prices for their good practices (Palm Done Right).
2. Nutiva
Nutiva is renowned for its plant-based superfoods, including organic hazelnut spread. It uses organic palm oil, which leaves forests and wildlife habitats untouched, contributing to a more sustainable ecosystem (Palm Done Right).
3. Hope Foods
Known for its dairy-free dips, Hope Foods uses organic and fair-trade palm oil in its products. It aims to revolutionise the fresh dip category by using the best environmentally friendly ingredients (Palm Done Right).
4. New Barn Organics
New Barn Organics is transparent about its use of palm oil, which is essential for the quality and taste of its products. Their Buttery Spread uses sustainable palm oil, aligning with their mission to provide trustworthy, dairy-free, organic food essentials (Palm Done Right).
5. Goodfish
Goodfish produces wild salmon skin snacks fried in sustainable palm oil. They ensure their palm oil is 100% organic, deforestation-free, wildlife-friendly, and socially fair (Palm Done Right).
6. Unilever
Unilever is strongly committed to sustainability. It sources certified sustainable palm oil and supports smallholders in achieving certification. Unilever works with various partners to ensure that its palm oil supply chain is traceable and sustainable (Unilever).
7. Marks and Spencer
Marks and Spencer has been recognised for leading the way in sourcing sustainable palm oil. They ensure all palm oil in their products is sourced sustainably, adhering to strict environmental and social standards (WWF).
8. Sainsbury’s
Sainsbury’s achieved 100% RSPO certification for the palm oil used in their products, demonstrating their commitment to sustainability (Caring Consumer).
9. Waitrose
Waitrose is another retailer that scores highly for its commitment to sourcing sustainable palm oil. It is transparent about its palm oil policies and ensures its products meet the highest sustainability standards (WWF).
10. PepsiCo
PepsiCo has committed to sourcing 100% RSPO-certified palm oil, with a significant portion coming from segregated supply chains. It also works to ensure that its suppliers comply with sustainable practices (RSPO).
These brands and many more demonstrate that it is possible to use palm oil sustainably, ensuring minimal environmental impact and promoting social responsibility.
Environmental Myths and Realities
Myth 1: Palm Oil is the Sole Driver of Deforestation
Reality: While palm oil production has contributed to deforestation, it is not the sole culprit. Logging, cattle ranching, and other agricultural activities also play significant roles. According to the World Wildlife Fund (WWF), palm oil is responsible for approximately 10% of permanent global deforestation, with the remainder attributed to other agricultural and industrial activities.
Myth 2: All Palm Oil is Unsustainable
Reality: Not all palm oil is created equal. Sustainable palm oil production, certified by bodies such as the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), aims to minimise environmental impact and promote ethical practices. Sustainable palm oil is produced with consideration for biodiversity, reducing deforestation, and supporting local communities.
Myth 3: Palm Oil Alternatives are Better for the Environment
Reality: Replacing palm oil with alternative oils like soybean or rapeseed oil could require more land and resources. Oil palm trees produce more oil per hectare than any other oil crop, making them more land-efficient. Thus, replacing palm oil with less efficient crops could exacerbate deforestation and biodiversity loss.
Sustainability Efforts in Palm Oil Production
Efforts to make palm oil production more sustainable include:
Certification Schemes: Certification schemes like RSPO set stringent standards for sustainable palm oil production. These include protecting primary forests, respecting indigenous rights, and ensuring fair labour practices.
Improved Agricultural Practices: Implementing better agricultural practices, such as using degraded land instead of clearing forests, can significantly reduce the environmental impact of palm oil production.
Corporate Responsibility: Many companies are now committing to using only certified sustainable palm oil. This shift in corporate responsibility is crucial for driving industry-wide change.
The Role of Consumers
Consumers play a vital role in promoting sustainable palm oil. By choosing products that contain certified sustainable palm oil and supporting companies committed to ethical sourcing, consumers can drive demand for more sustainable practices.
Conclusion
Palm oil, like many agricultural products, has a complex relationship with the environment. While its production has been linked to significant environmental issues, the move towards sustainable palm oil offers a promising solution. By understanding the myths and realities of palm oil, supporting sustainable practices, and making informed choices, we can contribute to a more sustainable future.
Call to Action
As consumers, we have the power to influence the market. Look for products with the RSPO label and support brands committed to sustainable palm oil. Together, we can help mitigate the environmental impact of palm oil production and promote a more sustainable world.
By fostering a balanced understanding of palm oil and its impact, we can better navigate the complexities of sustainability and make more informed decisions that benefit the environment and society.
Comparing Cooking Oils and Fats
When it comes to cooking, particularly in traditional fish and chip shops, the choice of oil or fat can significantly impact the outcome regarding cooking temperature, taste, health implications, sustainability, and calorie content. This guide compares these dimensions: vegetable oil, rapeseed oil, palm oil, beef dripping, and lard.
Cooking Temperatures
Vegetable Oil: It typically has a smoke point of around 200-230°C/392-446°F, making it suitable for high-temperature frying.
Rapeseed Oil: With a smoke point of approximately 204°C/400°F, it is also appropriate for high-temperature cooking.
Palm Oil: Palm oil has a high smoke point of around 230°C/446°F, ideal for deep frying.
Beef Dripping: This smoke point is about 210°C/410°F, suitable for high-temperature cooking but slightly lower than vegetable and palm oil.
Lard: Lard has a smoke point of around 190°C/374°F, making it less ideal for very high-temperature frying than the others.
Usage in Traditional Fish and Chip Shops
Vegetable Oil: Widely used due to its neutral flavour and high smoke point.
Rapeseed Oil: Gaining popularity for its health benefits and neutral taste.
Palm Oil: Preferred by many for its high smoke point and long shelf life, though its use is still controversial due to environmental concerns regarding unregulated farming in some regions.
Beef Dripping: Traditional choice in many fish and chip shops for its rich flavour, though less common.
Lard: Less commonly used today but appreciated for its distinctive taste in traditional recipes.
Health
Vegetable Oil: Generally lower in saturated fats, making it healthier. However, it can vary significantly depending on the blend.
Rapeseed Oil: Rapeseed oil is high in unsaturated fats and omega-3 fatty acids and is healthy.
Palm Oil: Contains both saturated and unsaturated fats. It is less healthy due to its higher saturated fat content.
Beef Dripping: High in saturated fats and can increase cholesterol levels and heart disease risk, according to some, while others believe animal fats are healthier than plant-based oils.
Lard: High in saturated fats and can increase cholesterol levels and heart disease risk, according to some, while others believe animal fats are healthier than plant-based oils.
Sustainability
Vegetable Oil: Sustainability varies widely depending on the source. Soybean and palm-based vegetable oils can have significant environmental impacts.
Rapeseed Oil: Generally considered more sustainable, especially if sourced from responsible farms.
Palm Oil: Highly controversial. Unsustainable production leads to deforestation and habitat destruction, but certified sustainable palm oil (CSPO) is a better option.
Beef Dripping: Less environmental impact unless beef is explicitly farmed for the dripping, which isn't the case.
Lard: Less environmental impact unless pork is explicitly farmed for the lard, which isn't the case.
Calories
Vegetable Oil: Approximately 120 calories per tablespoon.
Rapeseed Oil: About 120 calories per tablespoon.
Palm Oil: Around 120 calories per tablespoon.
Beef Dripping: Approximately 115 calories per tablespoon.
Lard: About 115 calories per tablespoon.
Taste
Vegetable Oil: Neutral taste, does not interfere with the flavour of the food.
Rapeseed Oil: Light and slightly nutty flavour, usually mild and non-intrusive.
Palm Oil: Has a slightly distinctive taste that can alter the flavour of food, which is not always preferable.
Beef Dripping: Rich flavour that enhances the taste of traditional dishes like fish and chips.
Lard: Provides a distinct, savoury taste that can enrich the flavour of many dishes.
Summary
Vegetable Oil:
Pros: High smoke point, neutral taste, lower in saturated fats.
Cons: Variable sustainability.
Rapeseed Oil:
Pros: Healthy, relatively sustainable, high smoke point.
Cons: Sometimes more expensive.
Palm Oil:
Pros: High smoke point, long shelf life.
Cons: Environmental concerns, higher saturated fat content.
Beef Dripping:
Pros: Rich flavour, traditional use in fish and chips.
Cons: High in saturated fats, sustainable because it is a waste product.
Lard:
Pros: Distinctive taste, traditional use in cooking.
Cons: High in saturated fats, sustainable because it is a waste product.
Choosing the right oil or fat depends on balancing health, sustainability, and culinary requirements. Rapeseed oil stands out for health-conscious cooking, while traditional recipes might favour beef dripping or lard for their distinctive flavours. Sustainability is an important consideration, with rapeseed oil and certified sustainable palm oil being better choices for environmentally conscious consumers.
What do you think? Add a comment.
Comments